Monday, October 11, 2021

Mount Airlie Milton - Restoration Australia Season 4 Episode 3

Host Anthony Burke meets a couple who've bought a huge run-down Victorian mansion in Milton, NSW, and plan to restore its regal beauty and throw open its doors to the local community.

You can watch Scott and Kate Lucas fix up a Victorian Homestead on iview.

Mount Airlie Homestead 34A Woodstock Road, Milton

Mount Airlie as depicted in ‘Sketches in the Ulladulla District, Town and Country Journal, January 20, 1885’.

It is clear by now that this season of RA is not about 'battlers' any more, and yet Burke keeps going on about the financial and personal costs along with the heritage issues. He is still going on about 'original' elements. Since most heritage protection only controls the external appearance, the idea that there would be any real constraint to someone with plenty of money being able to modernise an old building is a bit unrealistic.

The homestead is described in the Shoalhaven Heritage Inventory as being "undoubtedly the finest old home in the district" and is one of about a dozen important 19th century homesteads around Milton, five of which were built by the same stonemason, James Poole. 

An excellent Shoalhaven Heritage Study was undertake by Peter Freeman OAM, which provides context, but only briefly mentions Airlie in reference to its position in the range of architectural styles found in the district and as part of the Milton pastoral landscape.  Freeman's work is often very detailed and well informed, down to analysis of the wallpaper layers in some building. The Victorian-looking wallpaper at Airline is unceremoniously stripped off although it seemed more in character with the historical period of the house than the blank white interiors.

Airlie is on the Local Environment Plan and the NSW Heritage Register (presumably using Freeman's Words), says it is a:

Grand mid-Victorian residence, undoubtedly the finest old home in the Milton district. Notable individual design, derived from Classical and Regency influences. Associated with the Warden family. The work of the distinguished local stonemason James Poole. Survives in excellent condition with well planted garden and fine rural setting as part of the pastoral landscapes of the Milton district.  Local significance (Shoalhaven).

It is also described as:

A large two storey Victorian residence of symmetrical design. The rectangular plan features twin gables with circular louvred gables and there is a gabled rear kitchen wing. Construction is of stone footings and rendered stone walls with tall rendered and decorated chimneys. There is a concave iron verandah to three sides with decorative cast iron columns and stone flagged floor. The verandah is accessed by a low pillared staircase. Windows are arched double hung with matching plaster trims to all openings. Vermiculated quoining to both gables sections to the ground floor. The interior joinery, including fireplaces and stairs, is of cedar. Mature plantings of Norfolk Island Pines and Figs survive from its heyday as a major estate complex.   Modifications: The original shingle roof has been replaced with corrugated iron and the house has been renovated in recent years.

David Warden was the 'big man' of Milton. He arrived in Ulladulla from Scotland around 1837 with brother James, purchased the Mount Airlie estate from the previous, but now deceased big man, Alexander MacLeay, for £640 in 1849 Warden commissioned Sydney architect Mayes to desigh and  renowned local stonemason James Poole to build "Mount Airlie" between 1867 and 1868 (not sure why a stone mason is needed for a rendered brick building, but perhaps he was just a regular builder).  In 1852 Warden became the Post Master, then first patron of the Milton Agricultural and Horticultural Council in 1869 and the first Shoalhaven Council Mayor, serving on the inaugural Council between 1874 and 1877. Warden died in 1885, and the estate was split between four sons passing through the family until it was abandoned for a time. It had been renovated at some stage - probably gaining the corrugated iron roof in place of the 'original' shingles.

Burke calls it a "grand and important house that for decades has languished in disrepair and been closed off from the community". Opening it to the community is the part of the mandatory emotional backstory.

Scott and Kate had previously undertaken restoration projects in Melbourne, so it should all be familiar to them. The Heritage Register citation recommends a Conservation Management Plan be prepared. There was no suggestion in the show that this happened.  We are told that strict heritage rules may dictate what they can and cannot do. 'They’ll need to carefully navigate their way around these limitations. It will require some creative thinking on their part, so they don’t lose what makes Airlie House so unique.' Thats what the CMP is for. It provides the guidance needed to retain and enhance the cultural significance of the place. 

The owners did at least put out a call for old photos to help with their restoration - a commendable effort and entirely consistent with the Burra Charter:

Article 19. Restoration is appropriate only if there is sufficient evidence of an earlier state of the fabric.

Article 20.1 Reconstruction is appropriate only where a place is incomplete through damage or alteration, and only where there is sufficient evidence to reproduce an earlier state of the fabric. 

The only heritage issue raised in the show relates to the brick domed cistern in the courtyard. They have been told by the council heritage person that they have Buckley's chance of removing it. Probably saved them money anyway.   Milton Ulladulla Historical Society members Lyn Merrin and Noel Turnbull are compiling a list domed-beehive wells in the area as of 2013. Burke visits Noel briefly to discuss them. Several examples are shown, which are remarkably similar with their vented tower on top. I suspect there might have been a common hand in their creation. I haven't found the listing but the local paper makes mention. An enquiry to the historical society might be fruitful.

It cost them a bit over a million dollars to buy the place and they planned for restoration costs of $650-700,000 (such a price bracket clearly precludes the program from using the battlers card). Final cost was about $2mill all up.

But of course costs blow out. Why is it the case that cost over-runs are the norm? How come no one, from the small private resto to a multibillion dollar submarine tender can't get the numbers right? Is it because all the contractors and suppliers deliberately under-quote to get the work, knowing they will be able to claim variations due to some 'unforeseen' problem with dry rot or borers or hard to source timbers? Or they blame it on heritage constraints, even though they:

...worked with a heritage consultant, which brings another party into the equation that you've never had to consider before, The heritage consultant is there as the arbiter to say, 'whatever you're doing, it can't damage the fabric of the property (so) that people can't see further down the track what the property originally was'. (sounds like the claw - who decides which little green men will stay and which will go).

Some non essential landscaping, a new drive, and shifting the gates around chewed up a hundred grand. Not sure why though. Perhaps in preparation for a further subdivision?



Lifting the floorboards revealed termites of course. So unexpected.  Except why did they lift the floorboards in the first place? They knew the boards were bouncing, so what did they expect? Scott runs his own business in flooring no less.

Like the previous episodes, the place doesn't look so bad in the 2013 real estate photos - I wonder if they have a 'restoration filter' on their phone camera that hides the cracks and peeling paint.


The outside had already been done before the show start. We didn't get to see this part of the restoration. I imagine it was once bare grey render in imitation or Portland stone.  

A look at the builder's promo on their website suggests this is another tile, splashback and whitegoods-driven lifestyle renovation.  The sandblasted brickwork is a worry too, a throwback to those unfortunate defacements of the 1970s that destroyed the tuckpointed polychrome Hawthorn brick of countless boom period terrace houses. You can tell when bricks were never meant to be seen, because the bricklayer does a shoddy job, using up the short cut-offs and not worrying about the irregular bond pattern or stacked joints.


Another odd bit of misinformation appears when the verandah stonework needs repointing. Burke claims with some confidence that the mortar has shells included in the mix that are 'acting as aggregate'. No!, mortar doesn't need aggregate. The shells are probably residue from burning them to produce lime. Their mortar mix - 4 sand - 1 cement - 1/2 lime, with a handful of shells thrown in, might approximate the appearance of the old mortar, but won't match its strength. Burke redeems himself later, pointing out that the shells (calcium carbonate) were burnt to produce quicklime (calcium oxide), except before it could be used it had to be slaked (i.e. mixed with water and allowed to sit) to produce hydrated lime or lime putty (calcium hydroxide). the one bit of goot restoration advice in the show is thus muddled and useless


Burke seems to be trying to make some sort of statement about status in this episode, making scattered references to prestige, esteem and stature, power and visage surveying the landscape. He described Airlie House to the Ilawarra Mercury as '...a magnificent Regency style home with a great deal of prestige'. The landscape setting is mentioned a few times. It certainly did have a prominent landscape setting, and like many big pastoral properties created from stolen lands, it required an array of servants and indentured labor to make it profitable for the big men. Apart from a glimpse of the former extent in a painted view, we don't really get a sense of what was.


A bit of nearmap browsing turns up a number of nearby ruins, and begs the question, what archaeological evidence was lost either in the demolition of outbuildings and underfloor deposits, or from the extensive landscaping? was there any assessment?


The show raps up with some montages on stripping the kitchen, fixing the creaky stairs, the ensuite through the cupboard and pulling down the shed. I found it all a bit disappointing, and lacking in insight into either the history of the building itself, or the methods of restoration. I complained about the last series that it was Grand Designs meets The Block. this one has given up any pretense of being about restoration.

Just as a reminder, 

Restoration means returning a place to a known earlier state by removing accretions or by reassembling existing elements without the introduction of new material. (Article 1.7)

Maybe the rear shed was an accretion, and leveling the flagstones of the verandah was returning them to a known earlier state, but otherwise, it was just a standard bathroom and kitchen reno.


Wednesday, October 6, 2021

Eric Lyon's House Beaumaris - Restoration Australia Season 4 Episode 2

Host Anthony Burke meets a couple who are transforming their Mid-Century Modern 1950s house into a family home suitable for 21st Century living, in a beachside paradise just outside Melbourne.

You can watch Laura and Wilf restore their house here 

MCM is hot these days. A subset of house designs in the 1950s and 60s, it could well reflect the post-war optimism of a new generation breaking from the traditions of the past and even dismissing the 'Australian Ugliness' of transplanted British stodginess or imported American garishness. The council with the most MCM describes it thus:

Mid-century modern architect designed houses feature new design approaches, including use of light timber or steel framing; materials such as cement sheeting; flat or skillion roofs; north facing windows and easy connection to outdoor decks and gardens.
Sometimes structurally daring, the style of architecture is distinct for its use of clean lines, open plan layout and a different approach for maximising vistas and utilising natural light with floor to ceiling windows." 

I am ambivalent about the architectural and interior decoration style as heritage. Only because of the intrinsic biases that it embodies. On the one hand, the idea of the 'modern' attracted me early on. As a teenager at the end of the 60s and beginning of the 70s the changes in Melbourne were something to explore and enjoy, whether pretending to be a left bank intellectual at one of the few street cafes......


....or exploring the defunct nineteenth century development sites and watching the change from a brick and stone city to one of steel, concrete and glass. From Princess Bridge there was modern art in the animated neon of the the Allen's sign or the musical minimalism of the pile driver at the concert hall site. There was a feeling of prospect and promise in the new things happening.

On the other hand, it all seemed to be for rich people. I never went near Beaumaris, and few of the bright, open, spacious, modern houses of the period made their way to the northern and western edges of Melbourne. Spec-built weatherboards on floorplans little changed from the 1930s, migrant half-houses waiting for the money that would eventually allow completion, and big (to us) brick veneers, growing to two stories with arches, concrete balustrades, terrazzo and lions (or eagles) for the migrants who made good. This is the other side of modern houses from the mid century that no one fights to preserve.

I associate Beaumaris with middle-class families that looked down their noses at working class and migrant kids from the western suburbs. The kids didn't care mind - wealth to us was just another ethnicity; no better or worse than Maltese, Yugo, Pom or Skip. The fancy houses oppressed us with their demands to take your shoes off, to be seen but not heard, or just get outside in the fresh air. But that was just my prejudice. I only imagined what rich people might be like.

Eric Lyon's house has its fans. It is on Facebook. There is a conservation group gunning for it. It is well documented in a heritage study. It was even Domain house of the week. 

But on the other side are owners worried that heritage listing will devalue their property prices. 

Anthone Burke puts it: "It's not just your house that needs saving but a whole suburb worth of houses. How's that gonna go down in the hood?"

The City of Bayside twentieth century heritage study has had a difficult time; commissioned, then stalled, then cancelled. Then started again. 

 The Hun went as far as claiming that the "Heritage plan tears neighbours apart". 

Plans to slap a heritage overlay on dozens of Beaumaris and Black Rock homes have been scrapped by Bayside Council after furious homeowners spoke of anguish, anger and a community divided. The council last year sent letters to 51 Beaumaris and Black Rock residents, telling them their mid-century modern homes would be put on an interim heritage overlay until a study was completed.

Fiona Austin of Beaumaris Modern reckons there are about 500 good MCMs in her suburb and they would like to see about 100 protected although realistically, maybe only 50 would make it. But bayside council can only offer 19 for an interim protection under a self nominated scheme that the former head of the National Trust described as a "“cop out” that left “huge gaps, which will continue to emerge every time a significant place comes under threat".   

There is always a risk of course that many other owners get the demo crew in before their place gets a heritage listing 'slapped on it. Or after. On a Sunday. Or with a team of experts and lawyers. 

(N.B. heritage listings are always 'slapped' on, just like a place is always 'riddled' with asbestos. You can't just have a bit of either heritage or asbestos).

The council adopted an "...opt-in system whereby the owners of the relevant properties will be able to self-nominate their properties for heritage controls." As if! The Mayor reckons that “...council is committed to protecting Bayside’s heritage for future generations and recognizing the significance of mid-century modern architecture to our prized neighbourhood character.” Unless its worth more to knock it down of course.

RA ventures surprisingly close to this argument with ABC balanced vox-pops down the Bowls Club. The big heritage question in the well-shod neighbourhoods is always: "should the rights of private property owners to realise the maximum value of their biggest asset outweigh the communal desire to keep the character and amenity of their neighbourhood? Professor Burke is sympathetic to both sides of the argument but offers no answer.

The argument between the 'preserve character' and 'maximise profits' sides, however, is not new and has been going on since the beginning of the sandy streets subdivisions in the 1950s.  

Half of it is normal suburb, the other half is an Australian phenomenon. This second side of Beaumaris is the one loved by the majority of young families which have made their homes there since the war. The streets wind in and out a glorious tangle of tea-tree, banksia and gum trees. Through a curtain of boughs, you glimpse low, light, timber houses, white pergolas, oiled board walls, vivid splashes of color. You can stand in many populated streets and see nothing but trees and sensible modern architecture. This is the Beaumaris that attracted hundreds of progressive home-builders since the war. It has character, a happy quality of its own somewhere between a sophisticated studio-flat and a holiday camp. And it is thoroughly Australian. If anyone doubts Melbourne's accomplishments in advanced small house design, they should drive off Beach Road and wander the sandy back roads. (But be careful to pick a dry day.) 
(1954 'BUILDING AND DESIGN --', The Herald 8 June, p. 14.)_

IT is the one and only district in Australia where modern design and tree-conservation are clearly favored by at least half the population.

The origins of this attitude might go back to the Garden City vision of Wallace A Bartlett, who arrived from Sussex, England in 1937 to run the Dunlop Rubber Company and put forward plans to relocate the Montague Factory to a new site at Beaumaris where the company designed an Industrial Garden Village for 5,000 People (The Argus 9 Dec 1944 p. 8).  


It never happened, but the idea seems to have stuck.

The Lyon house at least made it into the heritage overlay (HO783), 
- 10 Valmont Avenue, Beaumaris - constructed in 1952 and extended in 1957, to a design by architect Eric Lyon is significant. 
The statement of significance (stripped of some of the heritage) tells us it:
  • is one of the earliest houses built in Valmont Avenue  
  • demonstrates the particular development phase of Beaumaris in the 1950s and 1960s, and post-war demand for housing in Melbourne 
  • is an intact and good representative example of an early mid-century modernist style house with very few changes 
  • reflects the profound influence of the International style, vis: a single flat roof structure; extensive panel glazed windows; ‘H’ shaped floor plan, zoned living, service and private areas; exposed structural elements and use of contrasting materials and texture; and the setting of the house which incorporates a courtyard and the retention of indigenous plants. 
  • is a fine, intact and rare example of the residential work of Eric Lyon, 
  • displays progressive concepts regarding the spatial integration on internal and external living areas that emerged during the post-war period. 
  • has manipulation of form, articulation of function, honest expression of structural elements and materials and a courtyard for outdoor recreation reflective of the progressive ideals of modernist residential architecture of the time.  
Love a bit of articulated function. 

I can't find much else by Lyon except a spiky Murrumbeen a Church and 17 Hepburn Avenue Beaumaris but I gather a lot of architecture goes unnoticed, since we have little public conversation about it, despite the democratisation of media in the digital space. Perhaps Eric, despite his evident profile at the time, worked quietly in the background.


The State Library gives us a glimpse of what it looked like when nearly new - some wooden shackiness appropriate to the beachside location.



and the cement tile veneer reflects the experimentation with new materials.



Just like the 1960s AV Jennings school I went to.  Who knew we were taught quadratic equations in cutting edge architecture? - why didn't anyone mention that crack in the wall? It makes me feel ill at ease.

We have plans:



and Eric's son John has a fabulous collection of slides and home movies, at least some of which look like they have been scanned, at least by the programmers.

Burke explains the stained timber facade as due to post war brick shortages. Except most of the rear is brick. So perhaps it was an aesthetic choice.  It went blue for a while.


The real estate agent had two bob each way when it sold in 2013:

Designed and constructed in the early 50s by renowned local architect, Eric Lyon, this classic corner positioned, 4 bedroom home is a testament to innovative, post war architecture. Lived in by Eric and his wife since day one, this coveted Deauville Estate positioned residence is now presented unchanged over the decades. In fact a step inside is like entering a time warp. The original fixtures and fittings have worn well over the years but this home really is ready for a complete restoration by an architectural purist. Or, if you are game, it could be a potential new home site (land size approx 725 sqm, 18m frontage). Featured in magazines such as Period Home Renovator, the experimental, timeless design provides delightful garden outlooks from every room. Equipped with multiple, purpose designed storage solutions, the home was built in two separate wings. All four bedrooms (with BIRs) are set to the north with exposed masonry block exterior, whilst the two living zones, lower tier home office and kitchen are set to the front. A brick wall with OFP to one side divides the front lounge and dining rooms and the every day living zone includes a servery into a separate kitchen with built in diner style meals zone and original milkmans delivery chute! Off the hallway, the bathroom is divided into three separate rooms. With wonderful garden views, timeless design and rich creativity, this classic Beaumaris home also includes an under level carport.

It's one that really didn't look like it needed restoration. Just a lick of paint and new carpets.


Except for the asbestos, and some tired wall finishes, and from the older aerials the rusty flat roof. Did it leak?

So what does Prof. Burke have to say about it?

His mantra is similar to the last RA host Harrison - "how can they update the house for modern lifestyles?". As if humans can't adapt their lifestyle to their environment.

Adapting to modern lifestyles seems to mean stripping out and refitting the kitchen and bathroom, taking out the wall to the dining room and replacing some tiles. An en-suit is essential. A few towel rails and a bathroom cabinet are reused, and the cork floor is kept, while the originally-planned but never realised deck will be finally built. Not really much to change then. 

The quality of the work is worth noting - which might be due to the $360000 budget, but more so to "head carpenter Adrian". He is really the star of the show - making possible both the ambitions of the owners, and creation of quality work. Adrian Moscatt of Top Level Carpentry.

When a shadow line timber is accidentally cut up, Adrian remakes it to original spec.

He makes a really nice door with wedge-tightened mortice and tennon joints. He also shows that wonderful self satisfaction craftspeople get from a really nice bit of work when he installs a hide-away sliding door with perfectly matched timber lining.

Another Restoration hero is Arne Groskopf, who is a quiet and reserved, and doesn't have a big head at all, but works quietly restoring all manner of things. He strips down and remakes the Beco light fittings - who would have thought such things would be part of the retro-fetish home decorator thing. Anyway -see his work here.  

So what is to be done with this place? While the floor plan remains much the same, the 50s feel fades when the old fashioned elements - stainless steel sinks, cupboard doors in the kitchens, old brown tiles, etc - are removed. The bright ceilings with their shadow lines, the cork tiles, the Beco light fittings, even the painted mural in the dunny all stay. So maybe I should concede that this is a pretty good restoration.


A few of the unusual elements that reflect both the owner's extra effort to tailor the house to his family's own needs (and lifestyle) are evident: Built in book cases abount; a sound system piped (really wired) all around the house; and a clever milk and bread delivery hatch that has found a new use for contactless, online shopping deliveries during covid.


But what is to become of the MCMs? All around units, dual occupancies and McMansions are going up. The measure of class aspirations have changed. The connection to the outdoors and openness to the street and it's suburbanite communities has been replaced by the home theatre and indoor-outdoor room. I presume people with architectual training design these too. Optimistic openness has been replaced by private insularity. Full realisation of their most valuable asset is more important than getting on with the neighbours. One biddy at the bowls club reckons if they want to preserve the houses, they can preserve their own.

Hopefully the trend will swing again. The residents and members of Beaumaris Modern will be campaining for it to happen in any case.








Tuesday, September 28, 2021

Baddeley Cottage Pambula - Restoration Australia Season 4 Episode 1

Host Anthony Burke meets Deb and Mike who are saving a rickety colonial cottage and digging for the true story of its origins.


The fourth series of Restoration Australia  has arrived on the ABC on Sunday evenings or iview. 

Anthony Burke is the new host. He comes with an impressive CV: graduate of Columbia University Graduate School of Architecture, Planning and Preservation; Professor of Architecture and Course Director for the Master of Architecture in the Faculty of Design Architecture and Building at the University of Technology Sydney; co-creative director of the Australian Pavilion at the Venice Architecture Biennale, presenting "Formations; New practices in Australian Architecture"; presented at TEDx Sydney; curated the Architecture and Design symposium "Architecture Makes the City" for the Sydney Opera House 40th Anniversary; exhibited at San Francisco Museum of Modern Art, the Venice Architecture Biennale, Beyond Media in Florence and the Beijing Architecture Biennale; architectural judge for the London Design Week 2014. He is "...recognised internationally for his work in architectural design, curation and commentary, specialising in contemporary design theory at the intersection of technology, urbanism and practice", and is researching Sydney's recent architectural history and its emerging new wave of "city changing projects" reshaping the Sydney CBD.

He is also described as a history buff.

In episode 1, we meet Deb and Mike Dunn, and Baddeley Cottage, an 1860s timber cottage with a variety of odds and ends as additions. 

The program seems a bit of a come-down for the host, who is left effusing about patching up an old timber weekender that is covered in asbestos. Burke's main contribution, apart from some throw-away and factually suspect lines about originality of fabric, seems to be an encouraging the Dunns, to "take their time". He tries to inject the obligatory dramatic elements of: a) time pressure, b) money worries, and c) strained relationship. He doesn't succeed. Apart from a moment when the restorers sit around the brazier proclaiming they are stuffed, it doesn't really look so hard. 

The cottage also doesn't really look so bad in the real estate pics. There is mention of asbestos, but this is just typical of mid twentieth century additions and these days just a matter of getting the right people in to deal with it. Perhaps like so much heritage, the abandonment and neglect that comes from redevelopment had taken its toll in the last few years. It was sold for $230,000 in 2017 after a subdivision that turned the large block into a housing estate to come, and left the cottage on a small parcel. 

The front shingle-roofed, two room cottage may be from the 1871, built by Charles Baddeley, who ran the local tannery. The south wing is referred to as the 1881 Post Office. The rear extension may be from 1948 (based on Lysaght Queens Head flashing). 

Some of the details revealed during the restoration are interesting. The intact shingle roof is not unexpected, but is well preserved, with one section encased within the roof space of the rear extension. Packing crate timbers (from Massachusetts and London) were used for internal walls, different types of galvanised iron, bead-edge lining boards and weatherboards, and various reused components such as multi-pane window sashes, help tell a history of changes. The discussions of these elements are rather muddled though, and make it hard to understand the decisions about how to manage change and impacts to heritage. There was only one mention of heritage that I caught: in reference to demolishing part of the section thought to have been used as "Pambula's first post office".  Some cuts in the miss-matched weatherboards and internal panelling are taken as signs of a former cart loading door. Possible I guess, but the ground outside is too far from the floor level to just back up a cart. And Syms Covington is recorded as postmaster at the Forest Oak Inn as early as 1854.


Burke's history is a bit dull, more bluffing than buffing.  He tries to be excited about 'original' bits and pieces, and we hear from Deb about her detective work documenting manufacturers' marks and evidence of alterations. But we never get a clear picture of what bits are from which era. 'Original' is rather overused in the show. The 'original' pressed metal is matched with 'original' bakelite electrical fittings. The Bakelite 'quick to make and break switch' didn't really come about until the 1920s. Electric power in the region may have been a fair bit later as well. In WWII there was only electric power from sunset to 10pm from a diesel generator.

The pressed metal ceilings and walls are described as material 'you couldn't have gotten in Australia at the time" and "you wouldn't have gotten an acorn if this was made in Australia'. I don't think this is true. The pressed metal is most likely an early 20th century addition from the Wunderlich catalogue.

More 'originals' are found in a post-1939 Coughtrie light fitting, and a dowel gate which we are told the 'National Trust has a whole technical document dedicated just to these types of gates'. Hmm! Could it be this he means? 


Perhaps the saving grace is that on top of all the demolition going on, we do get to see a bit of paint stripping and timber repair, while the structure is exposed and the tradies are given credit both on the show and in the follow up media. They worked for ages with the electrician and plumber. 

Tradies 'got the heritage' concept. Brickie Brendan O'Dwyer of Tathra learnt how to mix the lime-based mortar for the Glaswegian fire bricks.  Only Jeff Friede from America gets a name credit in the show though.

Deb also did her homework and went back to school and became an owner/builder. In a separate interview for the local paper Deb acknowledges the council's heritage advisor Trevor King, and Cecily Hancock, indicating that "they were really practical."

But why the distressed, distempered, shabby-chic look? Is it the fashion or just a personal quirk? The middle room with the exposed shingle roof (and exposed silver insulation) appears to be in the 'packing crate theatre set style'. 


Paint has been laboriously stripped off timbers everywhere, inside and out, but just enough to make it look like the job is half finished. Some rain brings out the sap to stain it again, but this is cleaned off with a special mix of something. It triggered a bit of deja vu from a previous series for me. Presumably there is a clear coat to protect the timber from the weather.

The last couple of years have been difficult for heritage. Illegal and legal demolitions make the news every week, while even the wins are just facades of empty shells. So it is good to see some people trying to keep the old material, even if they put it back together in odd ways.




Tuesday, December 8, 2020

Mittagong - Restoration Australia Series 3 Episode 8

Heritage devotees Val and John Jessop decide to buy and reassemble two old buildings - an old ghost town cottage and an old sawmill. What could be more difficult than that? (Season Final)

So we get to the final episode of series 3. John is from England via Africa and Val a Mittagong local with connections to the shale oil mining town of Joadja. They have already done a big renovation / extension, of an old school and church elsewhere. Now they plan another passion project to recreate a cute cottage with a fancy modern bit out the back.

Their business, Cotswold Furniture Collection, isn't mentioned in the show  but the end result of their involvement with the show looks like the sort of interior decorating magazine shoot that would be perfect advertising.

Their plan is to reassemble a house and sawmill shed from "flat pack" components. The house was moved from Joadja to Mittagong and at some stage was dismantled and the parts stacked in Willie Hall's salvage yard.

Willie is the secret weapon in their quest for a unique house - a particularly attuned builder, preserver of old stuff, and son of Peter Hall, the architect who rescued the Opera House. Hall is calm, quietly spoken and competent in all sorts of skills. He is the perfect foil to the fake drama of reality TV. He is actually real.


The sawmill was that of Alex S Blatch & Sons. It was still operating until 1998 when it had to close, supposedly because of the NSW ban on old growth logging according to one of the sons Graeme (SMH June 17, 1998). The Blatch family had offers for their "home-cut, wooden office, and corrugated iron shed from a local artist and a potter who liked the old, lived-in look," 

The sawmill was a landmark in Mittagong, and one of the last connections to the timber industry, that had for a century been the mainstay of the Southern Highlands.

But in the end it was cleared away for some drab townhouses.

Hall has a thorough grasp of good heritage conservation practice. He bought the house and dismantled it, presumably as a last option to prevent its loss. He took photos of the dismantling process and tagged the parts. He uses traditional construction methods and where parts needed to be replaced because of rot or termites, he used matching materials. He even has an old morticing machine to do the new mortice and tenon joints. This seems like a rare lost trade, but in fact is a simple piece of equipment to acquire and use today - its just that modern nail guns serve the same purpose with minimum effort.


So if a building has been moved from its original historic town and had a second life in another historic town, then dismantled and stored in for years before being moved again to a third site and reconstructed with building where it is married to modern materials, is it still heritage?


I suspect not, but Harrison goes on again about heritage practice needing to identify new building by cladding it in new material. But in this case it doesn't seem such an issue since so little of the build is actually original fabric or in its original configuration, while significant visual elements such as the cladding of both the sawmill shed and the house roof are done in new Zincalume removing any sense of heritage character. If there was no option but use new material, they still could have obtained proper galvanised corrugated iron for much the same price. At least then they could have some reference to Australian building heritage.

They have left some of the original internal wall finishes as a palimpsest of the layers of use and reconstruction, although the appearance is more of a contrived shabby chic, with mismatched boards, gaps and missing trim all over the place. It seems much was left behind when the house was dismantled.


With such a calm and competent builder, clients with patience and evidently adequate financial means and no council regulator or heritage advisor hovering over the building site threatening to close it all down if they don't use the right shade of Porters lime wash, there is little opportunity in the show for the usual fabricated drama. So instead it comes from the bushfires and the epidemic. 

As with the previous episode the virus keeps Harrison away but it is no loss as Willie makes a more authentic and personable narrator. What you aren't told however, is how this project is really just a bit of ordinary property development. The house/shed combo is squashed into a subdivided block next door to the Jessop's real house - a large and more prosaic late 20th century ranch style home on half a hectare. The original house on the block on the other side is now tight up against the fence, and the garden trees are all gone, making Mittagong a little less leafy.



The result is far more a pastiche of what passes for heritage on television, than actual restoration, but after the abominations on most of the renovation shows we don't really expect much more than this.



Gibbons & Masters Patent Brick